CREATORS OF THE COMPLIANCE TUNE-UP®

AARMR | ABA | ACAMS | ALTA | ARMCP | IAPP | IIA | MBA | MERS® | MISMO | NAMB

Showing posts with label Banking Examinations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Banking Examinations. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 1, 2015

Ten Core Competencies in a Compliance Management System

President & Managing Director
Lenders Compliance Group

In my view, there are ten core competencies to implementing a Compliance Management System, often referred to by its acronym CMS. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau requires it, state regulators are now asking for it, and investors want assurance of its application.

I have written extensively about the CMS concept and its importance in mortgage risk management. For instance, see my article on Creating a Culture of Compliance. Also, other articles here. When I speak on the subject, it is often the case that some in the audience actually have no idea about what constitutes the CMS. They think it is no more than a compilation of policies and procedures. But, the fact is that a viable CMS is composed of several integral features, each of which contributes to the cohesiveness of the whole compliance function.

Here’s a brief synopsis of the Ten Core Competencies that should inform a CMS:

1)  Loan portfolio, secondary and capital market management processes, mortgage servicing.

2)  Loan flow process, from point of sale to securitization or secondary market transaction.

3)  Internal Audit and Control Plan, including calendrical reviews, reporting protocol, rank and file training in all departments, and testing.

4)  Consumer disclosures, all loan types, federal and state.

5)  Mortgage quality control, not only random sampling, but proactive audits that target criteria.

6)  Record retention and maintenance, securing against unauthorized alteration or destruction.

7)  Marketing and advertising, including use of third-party services.

8)  Vendor, settlement agent, closing agent, and third-party vetting and approvals.

9)  Safeguards for privacy protection of consumer records and information.

10)  Reporting mandates to agencies, both federal and state, investors, and third-party relationships.

The compliance framework is built on the foregoing competencies. Destabilize one of them and it is possible that the others will crash like a tottering stack of cards!

Also, it should be noted that there is a growing expectation amongst regulators for a residential mortgage lender or originator to have a business continuity plan.

It is not necessary to consolidate all compliance policies and procedures into a single document. Nor does it require compliance managers to memorialize every action that must be taken in order to remain in compliance with federal and state banking law. In some cases, it may be enough for the compliance policies and procedures to allocate responsibility within the organization for the timely performance of many obligations, such as the filing or updating of required forms.

However, observed instances in which compliance policies and procedures were not followed or the actual practices were not consistent with the description in the compliance manuals, will likely lead to an adverse banking examination finding. Observed practices in areas that are required to be reviewed in accordance with specific regulations and in areas that include policies and procedures, but are not expressly required to be reviewed by regulations, will come under significant regulatory scrutiny.

What good is a compliance management system if it is not continually reviewed and, where needed, updated? In our work with new clients, we have found the following issues happening often:

·         Critical areas not identified, thus certain compliance policies and procedures were not adopted.

·         Policies were adopted, but were not applicable to the businesses and operations.

·         Critical control procedures were not performed, or not performed as described in the CMS.

·         Annual Review of the compliance function was rarely, if ever, implemented.

During examinations, an examiner may observe certain compliance weaknesses. But examiners review periodically, not continually, in most cases. The rest of the time, the residential mortgage lender or originator should be self-assessing the compliance programs in order to spot weaknesses, particularly with respect to identifying applicable mortgage compliance risks, and thereby ensure that the compliance management system encompasses all relevant business activities.

Tuesday, April 23, 2013

Waiting for the CFPB

My sources tell me that the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) will soon announce substantial monetary penalties and other administrative actions against a large nonbank. I guess it is inevitable that when such an announcement is finally out and about, humans  - and especially the financial services type humans - will be easily aroused to panic - which means the nascent, CFPB exam preparation industry will receive a steroidal boost. And the frisson of dismay and frenzy will be stirred up even further by the ambulance chasers, running to the rescue, with their merry band of products and services to quell the indomitable, bureaucratic brute.
There are plenty of compliance and law firms scouring the horizon for new clients that seek CFPB exam readiness. Indeed, I know of one such firm that has made fear-mongering into a fine art, whirring about and speaking at industry events where a surfeit of anxiety and angst may be supremely generated. As the affrighted crowd bounds into the arms of these ushers of deliverance, seeking the aegis of their singular protection, they are quite sold on a full scale risk assessment and sempiternal, on-going monitoring. But the prospective clients, sore at the loss of money in this endeavor, need not be too vexed, inasmuch as they do get action plans, some risk assessment tools, and assorted bric-a-brac of one-size-fits-all templates "specially drafted" for their own unique purposes.
Our industry is a strong bunch, survivors of the toughest real estate cycles, and accustomed to adapting to regulatory mandates. We have seen the largest fall and the lowest rise. We push back, when needed; and we push forward, when appropriate. We know that our industry is the backbone of the economy. Our future will not be compromised by cold sweat and consternation.
So, when considering the legal and regulatory compliance requirements of the CFPB, how alarmed and apprehensive should we be?
_____________________________________________________
Trembling before the Tsar
In the Tsardom of Russia, most people never met the Tsar. They met his agents, which at the time meant the duly constituted orders of functionaries who acted in accordance with the law. The people who did meet the Tsar, even nobles, were known (and even expected) to tremble in his presence. Like the custom required by English kings, the people who stood in the presence of the Tsar stated their views, when called upon to speak, and, upon finishing their statements, they left the reception chamber by bowing and slowly backing out of the room, always facing the Tsar. This kind of obeisance showed respect for the established order and reflected the insuperable power and primacy of the monarchy.
But we do not live in a monarchy and the CFPB is not the Tsar.
We need not tremble before the CFPB!
There are a set of guidelines that the CFPB requires for implementation by lenders, mortgage brokers, servicers, and others in the financial services sector. Most of these guidelines are not particularly ponderous, unless the foregoing entities hadn't been implementing them all along. It is not as if we do not know the importance of fair lending or proper data collection pursuant to the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA). There is no real mystery regarding compliance with advertising rules. Every company is keenly aware of the mandates set forth in the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA) and the Truth in Lending Act (TILA).
At this point in the industry's growth, who does not know about the importance of risk controls and risk mitigation? Who does not know about the central importance of responsible and knowledgeable management? How many companies willfully ignore consumer complaints?
A whole generation of bankers, lenders, brokers, and servicers have cultivated a heightened sensitivity to the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and Fair & Accurate Credit Transaction Act (FACTA), Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA), Bank Secrecy Act and Anti-Money Laundering Program requirements, Equal Credit Opportunity Act (Regulation B), Home Ownership & Equity Protection Act (HOEPA), Secure & Fair Enforcement for Mortgage Licensing Act (SAFE Act), the Fair Housing Act, the Anti-Predatory Lending Act, the National Do-Not-Call Registry, and monitoring third party service providers (sometimes neutrally referred to as "vendor management").
These are the sorts of areas about which the CFPB has an interest in ensuring consumer financial protection. None of the aforementioned is strange or new to anybody who has been paying attention!
I have said many times that 'Preparation is Protection' - and most companies associated with residential mortgage loan originations and servicing have been preparing, thus protecting themselves, for a long, long time. Many have been through numerous state and federal banking examinations, responding, where needed, with corrective actions. Not a few have retained competent mortgage risk management firms or in-house compliance advisors. Even those who cannot afford compliance counsel have participated in one way or another in conferences, conventions, and training venues in order to be educated in regulatory developments. Everybody now knows unequivocally that sales are cemented to compliance.
_____________________________________________________
Who's afraid of the big bad wolf?
As I wrote recently, the CFPB has considerable enforcement powers. Among other things, it can rescind or reform contracts, require the refunding of money to a consumer and demand other forms of restitution, mandate the disgorgement and refunding of various types of assets, compel the return of real property, cause fees and other compensation to be disgorged for unjust enrichment, require the payment of damages or other monetary relief, cause public notification regarding a violation, limit the activities or functions of alleged violators, and, of course, exact civil monetary penalties.
But, in terms of the remedies mentioned above, none of these administrative actions is really new. Virtually every state banking department in the country has most of these enforcement powers. Nearly all prudential regulators have many such authorities. Banks and nonbanks that have undergone routine examinations are not an unsuspecting lot, completely unprepared for the kinds of detailed review that the CFPB conducts. Having watched the CFPB in action, I can say that a firm that is adequately prepared for a state or federal examination should be prepared for a CFPB examination.
Is the CFPB's examination a bit more detailed? Yes. But most of the exam requirements are re-treads or the kinds of state and federal banking information and documentation requests or guidelines that are mostly customary and pro forma.

Thursday, January 13, 2011

CFPB: Signs Memorandum with CSBS

On January 4, 2011, the Treasury issued a Press Release, entitled:

Federal Consumer Agency to Partner with State Regulators on Supervision of Providers of Consumer Financial Products and Services, Including Mortgage Lenders, Private Student Lenders and Payday Lenders

According to the Press Release, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) and the Conference of State Bank Supervisors (CSBS) signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) that sets forth an initiative for state regulators and the CFPB to endeavor to "promote consistent examination procedures and effective enforcement of state and federal consumer laws and to minimize regulatory burden and efficiently deploy supervisory resources."

I have covered the CFPB since its inception as a potential agency to its actual creation through the Dodd-Frank Act. If you want to read some background, please feel free to visit our Library and download these articles.

  • Part III: Consumer Financial Protection - Bureau and Bureaucracy (10/10)
  • The CFPA Controversy: Asking the Tough Questions (10/09)
  • The Birth of an Agency (Consumer Financial Protection Agency) (09/09)

Or visit our general Archive for the compliance updates.

The MOU also provides that "state regulators and the CFPB will consult each other regarding the standards, procedures, and practices used by state regulators and the CFPB to conduct compliance examinations of providers of consumer financial products and services," including non depository mortgage lenders, mortgage servicers, private student lenders, and payday lenders.

In the Press Release, Elizabeth Warren, the Special Advisor to the Secretary of the Treasury on the CFPB, stated: "This agreement allows us to bring thousands of financial service providers out of the shadows and to begin the process of ensuring that all lenders comply with the same basic rules."

And Thomas Gronstal, Chairman of the CSBS, stated: "The formalized coordination between the states and the federal government established by the MOU will do much to create a comprehensive and seamless system of financial supervision and is a step toward a more cooperative system of supervision, which will benefit consumers and financial services providers alike."

Essentially, the MOU outlines three areas of cooperation:

1) Promoting consistent examination procedures and enforcement of state and federal consumer laws;

2) Minimizing regulatory burden and efficiently deploying supervisory resources; and,

3) Consulting each other regarding the standards, procedures, and practices used to conduct compliance examinations of providers of consumer financial products and services, including non-depository mortgage lenders, mortgage servicers, private student lenders, and payday lenders.

Best wishes,

Jonathan Foxx

Line-Webpage

Visit Library for Issuance

Law Library Image
Memorandum of Understanding: CFPB and CSBS Press Release
January 4, 2011

Post Separator-2-LCG

LENDERS COMPLIANCE GROUP is the first full-service, mortgage risk management firm in the country, specializing exclusively in mortgage compliance and offering a full suite of hands-on and automated services in residential mortgage banking.